PSP Fanboy review: Dungeon Siege Throne of Agony


Dungeon Siege handles the basics of a dungeon crawler very well. You begin the game with a choice between three very distinct characters, each with a focus on a different style of combat. As you progress through the game, you'll see that the customization options are quite plentiful, allowing you to have a character personalized to your playing style. Me? I prefer fast melee characters that can run in a battle, and then quickly escape (quick regeneration of health makes me a pretty tricky player to defeat!). Although you can't change the appearance of your avatar, you can assign very different movesets, and develop abilities that others may choose to ignore. It's very satisfying.
When the story begins, you'll be treated to a cutscene, and you'll find that all the dialog and events have been tweaked to reflect your character class. Although the core gameplay is identical for all the characters, it's a very immersive touch. There's voice acting for all the major dialog, making characters come to life even further. As you progress through the game, you'll find a very vast world to travel through, and slowly, as you complete your missions, you'll discover that this world has a ton of secrets, and will give you tons of gameplay time, at least 20 hours or more. The major points of the story are linear, but the order that you tackle missions is not, allowing you to completely miss certain quests. Completists will have a blast trying to unlock every single sequence.
Entering dungeons and other battle areas will reveal the incredible variety of enemies and equippable items there are in the game. It's actually somewhat overwhelming how many rings, cloaks, hats, shoes, and pieces of armor you'll find, all with very different benefits. It's nice that the developers reflect what equipment your character has on the in-game character model. In fact, the game features many visual niceties. Although not the prettiest game on the handheld, it certainly looks very good. With great visuals, great customization, great sound and an excellent orchestrated soundtrack, this game handles the basics very well.

With so much going right in Dungeon Siege: Throne of Agony, one can't help but want to like this game. However, there are some crucial game-crippling flaws that prevent this from being the excellent game it deserves to be. Firstly, there are a few technical issues with the game that really hinder the experience. Firstly, it's the most common complaint for many PSP games: the load times. They are awful, and they are everywhere. The initial loading of the game takes way too much time, as the game must load the 2K games logo, and then load the game menu screen and then load the loading screen (I'm serious about this), and then finally, your game starts loading. Waiting for the game to start is even less fun than reading that previous sentence.
The load times extend into other areas as well, too. For example, calling up your map brings a 30 second delay that makes the feature undesirable. The convenient warp points that are scattered throughout the world no longer serve their purpose because of the wait you must endure to get the teleporting map to load. Even more frightful, there's a delay in accessing your menu, where the game's crucial gameplay mechanics occur. While the developers map important functions to the D-Pad, and the shoulder buttons, it still doesn't alleviate the sluggish feel that the game features.
There are other glitches in the game as well. For example, enemy AI can be exploited quite easily with projectile weapons. As long as you stay slightly beyond an enemy's field of vision, you can fire away at your enemies, as they stand still, waiting to die. Dying in the game produces another unfortunate glitch where the in-game HUD map disappears after death, and will not reappear without exiting the game entirely (using the HOME button). The framerate is very unstable, usually choking when the screen is crowded, but at random times as well. Overall, these glitches make for a game that feels unfinished.

Even with all the flaws the game features, Dungeon Siege is still a strangely enjoyable and addictive game. If you're into dungeon crawlers, then you'll most likely enjoy this game thoroughly. However, long play sessions will reveal the simplistic, repetitive, nature of the combat (which seems to be more of a problem of the genre than this game specifically). It's unfortunate that there's no Infrastructure mode to the game as human companionship through this world may have been quite pleasant. With twenty hours of gameplay and great customization options, this isn't necessarily a bad purchase. However, like Untold Legends, don't expect the game to do more than any other average dungeon crawler.
PSP Fanboy Score: 6.5








Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Alien @ Nov 25th 2006 12:40PM
Now you see , I dont really agree , it isnt THE Dungeon Siege , but it deserves much more , its waaaay more superior to any h&s from the PSP ( ok , maybe not X-men legends 2 ) , and that means a lot . Not perfect , but still , I would rate it an 8 :)
Raviv @ Nov 25th 2006 12:42PM
Disappointing. I had high hopes for this game.
But anyway, I don't mind getting one for free :-)
madda @ Nov 25th 2006 12:45PM
Mhmm, many games on the psp aren't realy ready.
The psp is the better Handheld, but the software is just for making quick moeny, my opinion.
Greetz
madda
Alienowl @ Nov 25th 2006 1:02PM
Sounds like a cool game, but the load times seem unbearable. Waiting 30 seconds every time you want to see your map!
Alienowl
NuclearD3 @ Nov 25th 2006 1:04PM
I still might get it if i do not win. I played the first one on PC and liked it a lot.
pixelator @ Nov 25th 2006 1:15PM
Not sure, but I don't recall 'loading a loading screen' or a whole 30 seconds to bring up a map.
I didn't notice the HUD problem, but the ranged weapon exploit is indeed there for some enemies, though some seem to outsmart it, or have their own ranged attacks.
Generally, I'd agree the game has an unpolished feel (especially the level graphics) and there IS too much loading overall, but it's definitely better than Untold Legends, making it the 'best' dungeon crawler on the PSP right now (and the music is quite good). I'd give it maybe a 7.5.
pixelator @ Nov 25th 2006 1:20PM
Anyway, great review - gotta get some more of those churned out, Yoon! I'm on the fence as to whether Star Trek sucks or not. I need someone else's opinion because I can't form one of my own. >.<
Brian @ Nov 25th 2006 1:25PM
Sounds Like fun!
george @ Nov 25th 2006 1:35PM
I'm new to the PSP and still searching for the 'killer-game' for me. I've liked dungeon crawlers for quite some time and did have high hopes. Hopefully the developers can get the time to polish the game up for another release. I wouldn't mind giving it a try though.
In any case great review!
Jeff Kent @ Nov 25th 2006 1:35PM
Usually when these games get so so reviews I tend to like them a lot, but then again, I hate loading times.
Jason Frisvold @ Nov 25th 2006 1:36PM
While I'm definitely no fan of load times, I'd still love to give the game a try.. I enjoyed the PC Dungeon Siege game, so maybe this one will be worth it..
Rockstar seems to get load times right. Maybe they should offer to train other game studios... :)
Rob @ Nov 25th 2006 1:43PM
I totally agree with regards to the repetetiveness of PSP dungeon crawlers, let's hope somebody can make us a true portable baldur's gate.
Ben I. @ Nov 25th 2006 1:46PM
sounds like a fun game.......even though it does have the flaws....
hupsohl @ Nov 25th 2006 2:02PM
It sounds like a fun game, but I can see how some of those glitces would get to me. But of course I'd need a copy of the game to see for myself...
Shane @ Nov 25th 2006 2:07PM
Sounds like...fun.
mo1518 @ Nov 25th 2006 2:21PM
Love the in-depth reviews - keep them coming.
ineo @ Nov 25th 2006 2:23PM
...that game seems to...be a little fun...o well i hope i can try it out on my own :D
Christian @ Nov 25th 2006 2:51PM
I've read some really great things about Dungeon Siege. I'm eager to win....uuhhh..play it.
justice @ Nov 25th 2006 2:59PM
you guys need to keep up the reviews. id like to see some for upcoming games like final fantasy and others. thanks for this one.
Adam Reynolds @ Nov 25th 2006 3:00PM
I want this game. My friend's in love with Number two on PC and he want me to get it. But it looks good. (even with the flaws)
dbh1973 @ Nov 25th 2006 3:13PM
This is disappointing. As a fan of the PC games, I had high hopes for this one. So far, X-Men Legends II is the action RPG on the PSP. No others come close.
BTW, is there a NPC in the game that hawks the PC version of Dungeon Seige?
OXfire @ Nov 25th 2006 4:23PM
This is an excellent game. It is one of my first games for the PSP that I actually bought because I upgraded without knowing about the homebrew features of the handheld. I would give it an 8.
The loading times are the worst feature of the game, the rest are minor.
terrell @ Nov 25th 2006 4:44PM
i played the frist one on the computer and thought it was awesome can't wait for this installement on the psp.
Sally @ Nov 25th 2006 5:09PM
Alienowl, if it not very hard for you write down your tech info please. Game is great but some my friends told me the same as you.
Elias @ Nov 25th 2006 5:15PM
Maybe this game would stop me from play VCS.......NOT!,but I still would love to have it :)
Alan @ Nov 25th 2006 7:10PM
pick me pick me!
Roy @ Nov 25th 2006 8:07PM
This is the first game I played on the PSP that I actually finished. Its very good, although the only gripe about it is that I seem to get more loot for the other characters than for mine i.e. when I play the mage I get more items for the barbarian and the ninja / rogue characters.
Oh well. I hope they release a new Dungeon Siege game soon.
Dom @ Nov 25th 2006 10:52PM
Seems decent, I'll give it a shot sooner or later.
Silver R. Wolfe @ Nov 26th 2006 12:24AM
Alright, the only reason I'm posting here is to try and win that game. :3
I'm a sucker for free stuff.
As for the review, it's a good review. We need critical reviews like this. :D
Kenban @ Nov 26th 2006 12:47AM
Sounds like the game was rushed from the review but at least its another RPG for the system. Its a shame since the series is very good on the PC.
OyoyoY123 @ Nov 26th 2006 12:51AM
I want the game, either win it or buy it, so how about posting some videos. plz.~
vitiate @ Nov 26th 2006 3:15AM
I really enjoyed the PC versions. I hope this at least comes close, or is at least better than Untold Legends (which continues to collect dust).
TechRep @ Nov 26th 2006 8:12AM
Thanks for the review.
I saw this at a store and thought about picking it up... but, now that I have read your review, I will wait to see if I can win it from you.
YES... more in-depth reviews... PLEASE!
Danny @ Nov 26th 2006 9:45AM
I wonder if this is comign out in Europe.
Linker @ Nov 26th 2006 10:49AM
Well, I liked the PC game so I'll try to get one for free even if it's not that great.
keefurxxcore @ Nov 26th 2006 11:07AM
cool! nice review! too bad that the game loads too slow... what if you played it at firmware 3.00? because i read an article on www.pspupdates.qj.net that it loads at 222 mphz and it might load because of other games loading faster due to the new firmware.... anyone want to try it? im not upgrading! i want to savior homebrew ;)
Mulligan @ Nov 26th 2006 11:29AM
Though not very engaging the Untold Legends series still satisfied my taste. I'm looking forward to DS Throne since I enjoyed both Dungeon Siege PC games.
Paul @ Nov 26th 2006 1:06PM
I've enjoyed the Untold Legends series and played all the PC Dungeon Siege's (I've got a code from the PC Broken World game that should unlock something in the PSP version). If I could wait through Midnight Club load times, I'll give this game a chance (couldn't be much longer than that one).
rpnguyen @ Nov 26th 2006 2:22PM
me please
Andrew @ Nov 26th 2006 2:58PM
I don't care about the reviews. I would love to own this game.
Andrew @ Nov 26th 2006 2:59PM
pick me
siniux @ Nov 26th 2006 3:33PM
Sounds good! looking forward!
Adam Reynolds @ Nov 26th 2006 4:56PM
So no-one here is actully gonna buy it? THats sad...
Michael @ Nov 26th 2006 5:00PM
Never really enjoyed hack/slash games but it's never too late to get into it. I hope the loading isn't as bad on 3.00 though, seeing as how it increases the PSPs clock speed and all.
Dr. Rambo NYPD @ Nov 26th 2006 5:36PM
Jeg vil gerne have spillet!
Michael Anderson @ Nov 27th 2006 8:42AM
When you can cross an entire are quicker than you can load the Teleporter map ... there is a problem. I actually clocked the time to exit a dungeon, walk to the adjacent teleporter, activate it, teleport to the city, immediately reload the teleporter and return to the original dungeon and enter it again. The time - just over 4.5 minutes!
It is my favorite hack&slash PSP game (I find the loads much less annoying than those in XMEN 2) ... but it could have been much more.
Dan @ Nov 27th 2006 9:54AM
I was looking forward to this game too, but the reviews have been all over the map (IGN gave it 8.3, gamespot gave it 6.8)--thanks for another opinion!
Oh, what firmware was the test unit running? Those map problems seem pretty bad not to be addressed before release...
flyers241 @ Nov 27th 2006 10:12AM
i'm assuming that's a 6.5 out of 10? so playable but don't expect much.. i'd take that for free.
Sam @ Nov 27th 2006 1:26PM
I think it should get like an 8.5. Although the loading time sucks, it will still be well worth it and it sounds like a great game. If I was going to buy something I wouldn't base it on loading times. It has somewhat of good graphics and is all around a pretty good game. I will definetely be getting this game. By the way, that was a great review.
Sam @ Nov 27th 2006 1:38PM
I think this sounds like a great game. Although the game may have long loading times it still has great gameplay options. If I were to buy a game I wouldn't base it on loading. I'll be sure to get it. Anyways great review!