PS3 Fanboy review: WipEout HD

However, we wonder who WipEout HD is trying to target. There are three types of people in this world: those that love WipEout, those that are horrible at it, and those that simply haven't tried it yet. For those that love the franchise (us included), WipEout HD is perhaps, a bit too familiar. True devotees of the franchise have already played the sublime PSP games, Pure and Pulse. To find that every single track and every single song in the game comes from these two titles is a little disappointing. They're certainly great choices, but the wondrous effect of nostalgia doesn't kick in so soon -- Pulse came out less than a year ago. Instead, we're left with the feeling of "haven't we been here before?"
The second group of people -- those that are horrible at futuristic racing games -- won't find WipEout HD any different than previous iterations of the franchise. And the third group of people -- those that haven't ever played a WipEout game -- may very well find themselves displaced to the second group once they get their hands on this ferociously fast and relentlessly difficult racer. Sure, the new Pilot Assist feature will help beginner players steer away from the walls, but without the honed reflexes of a veteran, the game's learning curve is surprisingly steep.
Gallery: Wipeout HD

While 6 of the game's 8 tracks come from Pure, the progression system comes from the more recent Pulse. The campaign mode offers various grids for players to challenge. Each grid features a number of tasks to complete, and players will want to complete as many challenges to the best of their capabilities to progress forward. There are the self-explanatory Time Trial, Speed Lap, Single Race and Tournament challenges. In any of the time-based modes, players must simply beat the posted time to earn various medals. To earn points from races against the AI, players must simply place as high as they can.

One of the more forgiving aspects of the grid system is that it allows players to avoid challenges they may not be skilled at. Time Trial and Speed Lap challenges are, for the most part, very easy to clear. Getting enough gold medals in these events should minimize how many actual races players must compete in to unlock new tracks and new grids. To make things even easier, the AI Difficulty can be set before each race. Just like in WipEout Pulse, the AI difficulty and speed class aren't linked together.
However, even with the adjustable difficulty, the game may still be too challenging for casual players. Even on the easiest difficulty, we found players new to the series struggling to finish races. What makes the game's AI so hard to deal with (especially at the harder difficulties), is the game's rubberbanding system. Games like Mario Kart are notorious for their over-generous rubberbanding, which makes it easy for someone in last place to make it to the front of the pack (use a Lightning Bolt, a Blue Shell, etc). However, WipEout has the exact opposite phenomenon. Perhaps it's more realistic, but those that are in first place tend to lead the pack more and more. If you're behind by 3 seconds in the first lap, it won't be uncommon to drop to 7 seconds the next, and then 15 seconds the next. Posting continuously improving lap times won't even help.

Unfortunately, the game's weapons system is so fierce that many races become a fight away from last place. Opponent racers are constantly fighting, creating a virtual wall of carnage that players must surpass. Essentially, 3rd-8th positions will be in a persistent state of disarray, as the weapons hinder anyone in the back from progressing onwards. If you manage to make it in front of the mayhem, expect relatively smooth sailing.
This isn't to say the game is impossible. Rather, it just causes for some controller-throwing frustration. Perhaps that's exactly what veterans need, to compensate for the familiarity of these tracks. However, we do believe that even Easy difficulty isn't forgiving enough for series newcomers.
One of the best features of WipEout Pure makes a comeback in HD, and we're glad to say it's as fun as ever. The critically acclaimed Zone mode is back, and it works just like it did in previous iterations of the franchise. In Zone mode, players are strapped down in a vehicle that is constantly moving forward, constantly getting faster. The goal of Zone mode is to simply survive: as the vehicle reaches ridiculous speeds, reflexes must become incredibly well-honed to survive even the simplest of turns. What makes Zone mode even more special in this PS3 iteration is how much faster it can go. While the PSP games were limited to Phantom levels of speed, there are speeds well beyond that in the PS3 version. Just when you hit Zen, you'll realize that there's another class of speed above that. Already at that point, you won't be able to blink.

The color-changing tracks still pulsate to the beat of the music, although in a much more subdued fashion. It may have been changed to meet the requirements of epilepsy testing, but it's still undeniably beautiful. The incredibly stylized look of Zone mode is easily WipEout HD's most memorable -- and this is the one mode that everyone will be talking about once the game releases this week.
While Zone has made a glorious return, we're sad to say that another one of our favorite modes, Elimination, has not made the cut in WipEout HD. Featured in Pulse, this mode gave racers an enhanced set of weapons, limited shield rechargability, and a directive: kill as many other racers as you can. It was an incredibly fun mode, which changed up the gameplay quite a bit. It's omission is disappointing, and makes the game's feature set feel a little less substantial.
We're also sad to see the vehicle customizations of Pulse removed entirely as well. In the PSP games, players were able to create skins for their crafts online, and then download them into the game. It's strange that this PS3 version is missing two key features that we took for granted in the PSP game.

Yet, thanks to smart pricing on Sony's part, these omissions, repetitions, and flaws seem much more forgivable. At $20, it's hard to pass up. Ultimately, if you're part of the group that loves WipEout, you're going to buy HD, simply to experience the game in high-definition PS3 wonder. Yes, it's leaner and shorter than the PSP games -- but our PSPs were never pumping out 1080p graphics. Those that have never played a WipEout game will find HD a very exciting, eye-opening experience. The sublime presentation, the collectible Trophies, and the unforgettable Zone mode, make this an easy $20 purchase. But, when you're crying after an 8th place loss on Moa Therma, don't say we didn't tell you so.
PS3 Fanboy score: 8.0
See also:
PSP Fanboy review: Wipeout Pure
PSP Fanboy review: Wipeout Pulse









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
lobotomies4free @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:12AM
For those of us that somehow (sarcasm) still aren't convinced a PSP is worth it, I could go for some re-vamped year old games at a discount. The PSP GTA games did it onto PS2.
Lumines is coming too now and its not like it can really have much new content. Here's to hoping for patapon.
It'd be real hard for Sony to lose money on this kind of formula
FRANKIE @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:15AM
these GAME WILL rock cant wait for it getting day 1
Lionhart617 @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:16AM
Why don't you guys pay Kylie Prymus to write these reviews so that she makes an actual contribution to PS3 Fanboy? Sounds like a great idea.
strike @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:22AM
Why don't I pay to shut up? You don't have to bad mouth him, because you don't understand or aren't interested in the things he has to say.
Lionhart617 @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:32AM
"Why don't I pay to shut up? You don't have to bad mouth him, because you don't understand or aren't interested in the things he has to say."
You want to pay yourself to shut up? That seems rather unnecessary. And learn what criticism means. I'm sure Kylie enjoys reading both sides of how people feel about his/her writing (the good and the bad) rather than people just praising all the time and crying when other people don't feel like same way. Kind of like you.
It's like when you have a bad hair day and you ask your friend if he thinks your hair looks stupid. Do you want him to lie and say yes? Will you hate him for being honest and saying you look terrible?
We have some really simple minded people in the world. I wouldn't be surprised if you were just yet another.
strike @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:39AM
Sorry, I didn't think you were giveing construsctive critisizm ^__^ My bad
Metal_Gear @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:24AM
No reason any of those features cant become DLC in the future either! ^_^
Cant wait till Thursday, havent played Wipeout since Fusion on the PS2.
Kattleox @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:35AM
The only thing that I really wanted out of this game is Van Uber. Their absence in the more recent wipEout games has made me a little hesitant to buy them. I got Pure, but not Pulse, for that very reason; I love Van Uber, but they are just considered a second rung team nowadays and are only put in the games via DLC from time to time. It's really too bad that they don't just throw in all the teams from the get-go.
But for $20, it will take more frugality than even I possess to not pick up this one.
Pete @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:37AM
I'm not spending $20 on a downloadable game without getting a demo first. So how about it, Sony? Every downloadable game needs a DEMO!
Christian @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:40AM
Having seen the movie Hackers yesterday I am actually looking forward to testing this game out :)
Lionhart617 @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:41AM
"Sorry, I didn't think you were giveing construsctive critisizm ^__^ My bad"
Meh, you don't have to apologize to me. I was just being a little forceful since there are a lot of people on the internet that just can't handle the thought of someone thinking differently than themselves.
Just forget we had this conversation and all will be good.
strike @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:43AM
wat conversation?
strike @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:42AM
Wipeout was DEFINITELY my favourite game on the PS1, I borrowed it off my cousin for months on end, without giving it back.
maxpontiac @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:43AM
Andrew Yoon -
From what I gather from reading your review, it sounds like people will just have to learn how to play this game in order to beat it.
Correct?
heypaul @ Sep 23rd 2008 2:05PM
Yeah... And I think rubber banding is only when it slows down the first player and speeds up the last. You know, like a rubber band not letting the edges stretch too far. The guy in first place building a lead is just, you know, the guy in first not having mines and bombs constantly being dropped in front of him.
reakt @ Sep 23rd 2008 12:10PM
booo. How dare you try to dampen the excitement of Ps3-ers the world over who've been waiting months for this little gem to hit the store! :) OK, you're entitled to your opinion and you'll hear mine when I get my hands on this, on Thursday.
Patrick @ Sep 23rd 2008 12:11PM
I understand that this game will be brutal to series newbies, and I never really played the previous games. But does anyone have any idea how it will treat those of us who were decent at the F-Zero games? I would welcome a challenge like F-Zero GX.
deaftly @ Sep 23rd 2008 12:35PM
Fzero on the cube was beyond frustrating, prob the first game to make me ever throw a controller heh.
Andrew Yoon @ Sep 23rd 2008 2:15PM
F-Zero is much harder than this game. It's not that WipEout is too hard -- for people like myself that have played the franchise for years, it's more of the same. However, this game is supposed to introduce the franchise to a new audience. The score reflects that this isn't the most accessible game for everyone. WipEout fans, on the other hand, are getting a high quality product (which they've already played before).
Andy @ Sep 23rd 2008 2:15PM
Well crap... Now I'm on the fence about this. I was planning on buying Wipeout and Megaman this week, especially since I've made it to college without playing any iteration of either. But your review makes it sound like it'll be kinda hard for me to get into...
Maybe I should save my money for the Rush DLC for Rock Band?
rush @ Sep 23rd 2008 2:12PM
i am a huge wipEout fan so will try hard to be constructive ;)
i feel really sad you decide to knock one of the very few games that might take some skill to play. Does everything really have to be aimed at the casual market just because its big.. I have to assume you were playing on one of the lower speed classes, maybes you need to drink more coffee before next review :p
Jack Tretton @ Sep 23rd 2008 1:06PM
Despite having some of the best soundtracks in gaming, does this one support custom soundtracks?
Darkdrium777 @ Sep 23rd 2008 1:27PM
Yes
John S @ Sep 23rd 2008 2:22PM
yes it does
Ty @ Sep 23rd 2008 1:13PM
This is a cheap Wipeout game in the vain of older PlayStation Wipeout games. And by that I mean Wipeout XL and Wip3out. Atleast thats what it looks like. I'm getting it.
More importantly I'm banking on the fact that you all need to remember that a completely separate game called Wipeout PS3 is still currently in development. Its probably going to be the same vain. A PS3 1080P 60 fps graphic orgy. Consider that this entree of a game is just an appetizer for Wipeout Pulse. Its a cheap download that delivers Wipeout. It may be a high quality rereun buts its still worth it.
Wipeout PS3 2009
Evi1d33d @ Sep 23rd 2008 1:16PM
I wonder if I should get Burnout Paradise or this game...
Nugent @ Sep 23rd 2008 1:44PM
Regarding the reviewer's comments about difficulty, as a casual fan of Wipeout, I don't think Wipeout has ever been friendly to newbies. I haven't played all the Wipeout games, but all the ones I've played are pretty difficult.
I think this game is a smart move for Sony. It's a graphic showcase for the PS3, its an established franchise with a solid fan base, and its cheap. I think this game is an unsung system seller, if Sony advertises it properly.
Vcize @ Sep 23rd 2008 2:36PM
I fall into category 3 and I'll be picking it up. I wish it were coming out on disc so I could resell it if I didn't like it, but at 20 bucks it's worth the risk.
Skunk Ape @ Sep 23rd 2008 3:06PM
I've always loved Wipeout since the first one came out, but I've never played Pulse or Pure as I hate portable systems. I can't f-ing wait for this game.
scratch @ Sep 23rd 2008 3:57PM
I will echo some others, and say that your generalizations regarding wipeout lovers and Pure and Pulse are inaccurate.
I love Wipeout. Played the original and XL on the PS1, and I own the Wipeout Fusion on the PS2. Great games, great music. Sometimes frustratingly difficult, but mostly only in a challenging way.
I dont own a PSP, and I dont really know anyone that does. So I havent played Pure or Pulse. I am super-excited about Wipeout HD.
I would recommend it to anyone that likes challenging, visually stimulating racing games, and bumping techno of course.
Ted @ Sep 23rd 2008 4:37PM
I have never played WipEout before so I'm in category 3 but this game look fun, reasonably priced and trophy's!
I will still be picking it up on Thursday, Cant WAIT!
pat1202003 @ Sep 23rd 2008 5:09PM
I am so getting this on Thursday!
I hope Elimination mode, vehicle customizations, and more tracks and ships will come out as a add-on later. And they actually come out in the US (unlike Pulse add-ons)
JoeTheBlow @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:54PM
GAH! You seem to have forgot another group of people!
Those who love Wipeout, but saw no reason to buy a PSP and the games, so have been starved of floaty ship action since the PS1 days!
So for us, fuck Pulse and Pure similarities, this is The Shit.
DrunkRaba @ Sep 23rd 2008 7:21PM
I'm also of category 3. I normally stick to cars for racing but this game just looks amazing and Zone mode especially. I wish there was a demo but I will have to get this.
kingtalo @ Sep 23rd 2008 11:51PM
I'll be grabbing this one up day one as well. It's true that it's not the easiest game to master (and content wise pure and pulse have this one beat), but at 20$ and with assblasting garFX it's a steal. Hopefully the DLC will be decently priced, and patches can iron out a lot of problems/introduce new features.
Hopefully this will mark ag-racing's glorious return, and the next true iteration will indeed implode our brains.
yehmate @ Sep 24th 2008 8:27AM
wipeout is great
yehmate @ Sep 24th 2008 8:41AM
regarding noobs,the game is set up to get you good at it with time trials and speed laps.i played the psp version of pure and it was gd but your playing with an awkward controller, i think this is definitley well worth the money.personally i thought the review sounded quite negative,and i think zone is the worst feature on the game.roll on thursday man.
deafwing @ Sep 24th 2008 8:37PM
hmm a review approach based on demographic existence .. interesting but I guess when a game is so similliar to its predecessors, what else is there to do?
I'm so deeply categorized in the first demographic that I honestly don't mind the remake ... how about telling us what the DLC for this baby will be like? (^_ ^ )
IHateBioshock @ Sep 24th 2008 9:03PM
Wipeout was the first game I ever played on a PS system (bought it on UK launch day along with the console - £44 for game £299 for console and that was then.. makes modern stuff seem cheap actually!).
Anyway, I never had a PS2 and ownned no other wipeouts (played 2097 though!) so I'm definitely getting this one - this was part of the reason I bought a PS3. I hope they do a 'Full' new wipeout at some stage (bluray) with the missing features.
Eggy @ Sep 25th 2008 6:37PM
Good review. I only played an hour or so but I give it a 9. The detail just blows you away and zone mode looks incredible in HD.
deafwing @ Sep 26th 2008 3:07AM
hmm Just hit up a hour too myself just now ... but yea, for some reason, I guess the reviewer approached this review dispationately as possible ... the PSN download is solid ... long live DLC!
Yet, I agree, if you played the series as much as I have (especially pure and pulse) these tracks look as friendly as the back of your hand ... but the sheer sheen presented by SCEE for this remake is well worth the bandwith and $$$.
Dunk @ Sep 26th 2008 9:31AM
I walked into a shop in Northampton just prior to Wipeout 2097 coming out and an advert for it was playing on the in-shop TV. I was in the market for my first ever console and discussed the options with the shop assistant. He thought the Playstation was slightly better than the Sega Saturn and when I found out that the advertised game was only out for the Playstation, it sold me the console. Over a decade on and my choice of console is still partly made based on knowing that a version (or two) of Wipeout will be released on the Sony machine.
BTW, this game is only hard to master the controls on if you haven't the brains to ease off and use the various braking techniques around certain corners.
A top top top franchise.
Jeff @ Sep 26th 2008 9:01PM
I don't agree with this review at all... I've never played a futuristic racing game before, and I just got wipeout and I love it! Also, I don't find it a "ferociously fast and relentlessly difficult racer" I got first in my first two online tournaments. AND, if they don't like the soundtrack, just use the custom soundtrack feature, duuh :P
required @ Nov 3rd 2008 11:56PM
This game is horrible and needs to be fixed. It's much too hard and no I'm not new to the series. Worst money spent on the PS3 to date. Seriously. The PSP versions are much better in every aspect (in many ways they even look better).